https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/2019/09/11/how-us-troops-fought-one-war-afghanistan-military-deployments-by-numbers/
Early Thursday afternoon, President Biden announced that "it is time to end America's longest war." Throughout this two-decade war that had resulted from the 9/11 attacks of 2001, 2,300 of the 775,000 US troops deployed were killed in action. In a speech from the White House Treaty Room, President Biden stated that the US has accomplished its main objective in Afghanistan which was ensuring that the country did not continue as a base of operations for terrorist cells to attack the homeland again. Hence, he believes "it is time for American troops to come home." Due to the successful elimination of former al-Qaida leader, Osama Bin Laden, a decade ago, Biden believes that the reasons for America's remaining presence in Afghanistan have become unclear. As a result, he plans to successfully withdraw all US forces from Afghanistan by September 11th, the anniversary of the 2001 attacks that started the war. Despite all this, Biden's announcement came with many concerns from the US intelligence agencies that the total withdrawal from Afghanistan could leave the country in chaos and possibly undo all the progress that has been made over the last decade.
With some arguing that Biden's postponed withdrawal could cost America more money in funding and others arguing that the withdrawal could have negative consequences in Afghanistan, this unveils a dilemma that President Biden now has the burden of answering for. Furthermore, the mass media will certainly play a significant role in influencing public opinion as the events of this withdrawal unfold, depending on the certain aspects of this historical event they choose to emphasize in the news and those they choose to brush under the rug.

This is a very informative post! Biden's pulling of US soldiers from Afghanistan is certainly causing a lot of conversation on if it was the right move or not. As you said, US soldiers in Afghanistan has helped keep terrorist cells from taking over the country and possibly attacking US soil. I just hope that if the troops are to be pulled, that these terrorist cells will not take advantage of this and begin trying to retake the country as then it will just be a cycle.
ReplyDeleteRashad,
ReplyDeleteGlad to see someone is interested in issues not only in this country, but also issues transpiring in other parts of the world that ultimately could affect our lives and the country as a whole. In regards to Afghanistan and the withdrawal of U.S. troops, there is no easy answer. It could be a lose-lose decision or a win-win, only time will tell. In your blog you stated, “US has accomplished its main objective in Afghanistan which was ensuring that the country did not continue as a base of operations for terrorist cells to attack the homeland again,” and “ elimination of former al-Qaida leader, Osama Bin Laden, a decade ago, Biden believes that the reasons for America's remaining presence in Afghanistan have become unclear.” Elimination of Bin Laden is meaningless now as it was at the time of his elimination. al-Qaida was fragmented by then and the remains of the organization was under control by other leaders. Currently, the Taliban is continually launching attacks on American and coalition forces, and have walked away from talks with the U.S. and Afghanistan intended to form a power sharing arraignment. Why, they are smart and very patient people, not only have they outlasted us, but knowing this new administration is intent on leaving, why negotiate, soon they know they will take control and it will be business as it was twenty years ago. Islamic State, (ISIS) is also waiting in the wings to fill the void the coalition forces are going to leave.
President Biden during the campaign continually stated the he would listen to the military brass and the scientific community, thus separating himself from Trump. What do the top military officers and the Secretary of Defense have to say regarding the withdrawal? According to the Wall Street Journal, “President Biden’s decision to remove all U.S. troops from Afghanistan ran counter to the recommendations of his top military commanders, who feared it could undermine security in the country. Gen. Frank McKenzie, the commander of U.S. forces in the Middle East, Gen. Austin “Scott” Miller, who leads NATO forces in Afghanistan, and Gen. Mark Milley, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, all recommended retaining the current force of 2,500 troops while stepping up diplomacy to try to cement a peace agreement, U.S. officials say. Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin, himself a retired military commander for the region, shared the concerns of the senior officers, cautioning that withdrawing all U.S. troops would suspend what amounted to an insurance policy for maintaining a modicum of stability in the country, the officials said.”
So much for campaign promises. As far as the mass media and how they respond. The liberal media will support Biden even when Afghanistan is under control of the Taliban and ISIS, Biden was who they wanted and they got. As the saying goes, “be careful what you wish for.”
Source:
Wall Street Journal, “Biden Overrode Generals’ Advice On Afghanistan,” April 19, 2021
Herb Porath April 19, 2021
ReplyDeleteRashad,
Glad to see someone is interested in issues not only in this country, but also issues transpiring in other parts of the world that ultimately could affect our lives and the country as a whole. In regards to Afghanistan and the withdrawal of U.S. troops, there is no easy answer. It could be a lose-lose decision or a win-win, only time will tell. In your blog you stated, “US has accomplished its main objective in Afghanistan which was ensuring that the country did not continue as a base of operations for terrorist cells to attack the homeland again,” and “ elimination of former al-Qaida leader, Osama Bin Laden, a decade ago, Biden believes that the reasons for America's remaining presence in Afghanistan have become unclear.” Elimination of Bin Laden is meaningless now as it was at the time of his elimination. al-Qaida was fragmented by then and the remains of the organization was under control by other leaders. Currently, the Taliban is continually launching attacks on American and coalition forces, and have walked away from talks with the U.S. and Afghanistan intended to form a power sharing arraignment. Why, they are smart and very patient people, not only have they outlasted us, but knowing this new administration is intent on leaving, why negotiate, soon they know they will take control and it will be business as it was twenty years ago. Islamic State, (ISIS) is also waiting in the wings to fill the void the coalition forces are going to leave.
President Biden during the campaign continually stated the he would listen to the military brass and the scientific community, thus separating himself from Trump. What do the top military officers and the Secretary of Defense have to say regarding the withdrawal? According to the Wall Street Journal, “President Biden’s decision to remove all U.S. troops from Afghanistan ran counter to the recommendations of his top military commanders, who feared it could undermine security in the country. Gen. Frank McKenzie, the commander of U.S. forces in the Middle East, Gen. Austin “Scott” Miller, who leads NATO forces in Afghanistan, and Gen. Mark Milley, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, all recommended retaining the current force of 2,500 troops while stepping up diplomacy to try to cement a peace agreement, U.S. officials say. Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin, himself a retired military commander for the region, shared the concerns of the senior officers, cautioning that withdrawing all U.S. troops would suspend what amounted to an insurance policy for maintaining a modicum of stability in the country, the officials said.”
So much for campaign promises. As far as the mass media and how they respond. The liberal media will support Biden even when Afghanistan is under control of the Taliban and ISIS, Biden was who they wanted and they got. As the saying goes, “be careful what you wish for.”
Source:
Wall Street Journal, “Biden Overrode Generals’
I feel like this is not a bad plan. Seeing as they are on the road to back to normalcy for them I think let them be. There are so many other big issues we can focus time and money on. Also Afghanistan does not pose near as big of a threat as other countries like China or Russia.
ReplyDeleteHey Quincy I really appreciate you making a blog about this topic. Our news is filled with so much nowadays most people are unaware of this even being an issue. But the possibilities and ramifications this could have on not just the U.S. but the world is massive. It’s going to be interesting to see how this plays out as there have been many promises made by people to withdrawal troops in which it was mostly a lie or at the least an unfulfilled promise. With so many polarizing topics nationally taking up our news coverage I’ll be curious to see how much attention this gets and if it the process will seemingly happen unknown to the greater public.
ReplyDelete